Have you ever looked at a design and thought, “What were they thinking?” We all have. Design is subjective. But some choices are objectively…bad. 2024 brought its fair share of head-scratching design moments. We’re here to dissect the worst design fails from 2024. We’ll explore why they didn’t work. We’ll also discuss what we can learn from them. Get ready for some serious design side-eye! Did you spot any of these trends?
The Reign of the Unreadable Font
Typography matters, right? Of course! But some designers in 2024 seemed to forget this. We saw fonts that were so stylized they were illegible. Think overly ornate scripts on websites. Or ultra-thin fonts used for body text. The result? Users strained their eyes. They quickly bounced from the site. Good design communicates clearly. It shouldn’t be a visual puzzle. Legibility is key. Always. Remember that.
Why did it fail?
- Poor Accessibility: These fonts exclude users with visual impairments.
- Frustration: People don’t want to work hard to read.
- Loss of Message: If they can’t read it, they can’t understand it.
What we can learn: Prioritize clarity. Choose fonts that are easy to read. Consider accessibility guidelines.
Maximalism Gone Mad: Overloaded Interfaces
Minimalism had its moment. But 2024 saw a surge in maximalism. This isn’t inherently bad. But many designs took it way too far. We’re talking about interfaces crammed with elements. Colors clashed. Animations were distracting. There was no breathing room. Users felt overwhelmed. Information got lost in the noise. The result was visual chaos. Would you want to deal with that daily?
Why did it fail?
- Cognitive Overload: Too much information overwhelms the user.
- Poor User Experience: It’s hard to find what you need.
- Visual Fatigue: It’s exhausting to look at.
What we can learn: Maximalism can work. But balance is key. Prioritize information. Use visual hierarchy. Give elements room to breathe.
The “Blob” Aesthetic: Uninspired Organic Shapes
Remember the blob trend? Those amorphous, blob-like shapes were everywhere. They were meant to feel organic. But they quickly became overused. They lacked personality. They felt generic. Many designs looked the same. The result was a sea of blandness. Did you like the blobs?
Why did it fail?
- Lack of Originality: It became a cliché.
- Missing Context: Blobs don’t always make sense.
- Visual Monotony: Everything looked the same.
What we can learn: Trends come and go. Don’t blindly follow them. Find unique ways to express your brand.
AI-Generated Imagery: The Uncanny Valley Strikes Back
AI image generators are powerful tools. But they aren’t a replacement for human creativity. 2024 saw a rise in AI-generated images used poorly. Faces were distorted. Hands had too many fingers. Details were off. The result was unsettling. It fell squarely into the “uncanny valley.” People noticed. It eroded trust. Did you trust the AI-generated images you saw?
Why did it fail?
- Lack of Authenticity: It felt artificial.
- Uncanny Valley Effect: It was creepy.
- Ethical Concerns: Copyright and authorship are murky.
What we can learn: Use AI as a tool. Don’t rely on it entirely. Pay attention to detail. Ensure authenticity. Consider the ethical implications.
The Color Clashes: When Hues Attack
Color is powerful. It evokes emotion. It attracts attention. But some color palettes in 2024 were…aggressive. Clashing hues fought for dominance. There was no harmony. The result was visually jarring. People averted their eyes. Were your eyes hurting from seeing these clashing colors?
Why did it fail?
- Visual Discomfort: It’s hard to look at.
- Poor Communication: Colors can send the wrong message.
- Lack of Harmony: Colors should complement each other.
What we can learn: Understand color theory. Use color palettes thoughtfully. Test your choices. Get feedback.
The Missing White Space: Claustrophobic Design
White space is crucial. It provides a visual breathing room, guides the eye, and improves readability. But some designs in 2024 seemed allergic to it. Elements were crammed together. There was no room to breathe. The result was claustrophobic. Users felt overwhelmed.
Why did it fail?
- Poor Readability: Text is hard to read.
- Cognitive Overload: Too much visual clutter.
- Unpleasant Experience: It feels cramped and overwhelming.
What we can learn: Embrace white space. It’s not wasted space. It’s a design element. Use it to improve clarity and usability.
Accessibility Neglect: Ignoring Users with Disabilities
Accessibility is non-negotiable. Every design should be inclusive. But many designs in 2024 failed to consider users with disabilities. Poor color contrast, lack of alt text, and inaccessible navigation were common issues. The result was exclusion. Users felt ignored.
Why did it fail?
- Exclusion: It excludes users with disabilities.
- Legal Issues: Accessibility is often legally required.
- Moral Obligation: It’s the right thing to do.
What we can learn: Prioritize accessibility from the start. Follow accessibility guidelines. Test your designs with assistive technologies.
Design Fails with Annoying Animations: Movement for the Sake of Movement
Animations can enhance user experience. But some animations in 2024 were simply annoying. They were distracting, served no purpose, and slowed down the site. The result was frustration. Users quickly closed the tab.
Why did it fail?
- Distraction: It pulls focus from important content.
- Performance Issues: It can slow down websites.
- Annoyance: It can be irritating to users.
What we can learn: Use animations sparingly. Ensure they serve a purpose. Optimize for performance. Don’t annoy your users.
The Carousel of Doom: Hidden Content
Carousels are tempting. They let you showcase multiple items in one space. But they often hide content. Users rarely scroll through all the slides. Important information gets missed. The result is wasted space.
Why did it fail?
- Poor Visibility: Content gets buried.
- Low Engagement: Users rarely interact with them.
- Accessibility Issues: They can be difficult to navigate.
What we can learn: Avoid carousels. Find better ways to showcase content. Prioritize key information. Make it easily accessible.
Lessons Learned from the Design Graveyard
2024 gave us some valuable lessons. We learned what not to do. We saw the consequences of poor design choices. Now it’s time to move forward. We can create better, more user-friendly experiences. Let’s learn from these “design fails”. Let’s build a future of thoughtful, inclusive design. What design trends do you hope never return?
Hungry for more? If so, check out our article about the top 10 graphic design trends in 2025. In addition, you can find other inspiring articles in the Graphic Design section on WE AND THE COLOR. Header image by Drobot Dean (via Adobe Stock).
Subscribe to our newsletter!
